Wider den Konsens!
Darauf muss man erst mal kommen!
Spreeblick stellt einen netten Zeitvertreib für zwischendurch vor:
- Amazon besuchen (wegen Vielfalt am besten dot com!)
- Ein Klassiker der Popmusik oder Literaturgeschichte bibliographieren
- Die Kundenbewertungen (Customer Reviews) aufrufen
- Sortieren nach "Schwächster Wertung" (Lowest Ratings)
- Staunen, Wundern, Freuen!
Ich versuchs mal umgekehrt: Wer kommt drauf?
[The Book] is a pitiful example of German literature. What is told to the reader in ~750 pages could be edited into probably 300 pages. Mann seems to be obsessed with eating breakfast, because it seems that half the novel is describing their meals. The novel itself is long, tedious, and so meticiously divided that the reader wonders if [the author] spent more time writing the novel or diving them up into dainty sections.
I don't owe [the author] or his publishers anything. If you have a good idea why not just write it on a page and publish the one page? If you want to use the good idea to write a book it has to be entertaining or readable or at least interesting. Looking at the other reviews by people who have given it five stars I wonder if I have just read the same book. There are no new paragraphs when he changes the dialogue from one person to the next and the publishers surely should have done this for him because, in not doing so, you keep having to stop to work out who is saying what. The book just crawled along and was so boring. After about sixty pages I remember saying 'alright, I get it, do something else!' Part of me wonders if it's like the emperors new coat and I should just join in with five stars. Although the other reviewers praise the book they don't seem to actually say WHY it's a good book. It was pure mince.
I thought the movie was rather good. After about 250 pages I quit.
Spreeblick stellt einen netten Zeitvertreib für zwischendurch vor:
- Amazon besuchen (wegen Vielfalt am besten dot com!)
- Ein Klassiker der Popmusik oder Literaturgeschichte bibliographieren
- Die Kundenbewertungen (Customer Reviews) aufrufen
- Sortieren nach "Schwächster Wertung" (Lowest Ratings)
- Staunen, Wundern, Freuen!
Ich versuchs mal umgekehrt: Wer kommt drauf?
[The Book] is a pitiful example of German literature. What is told to the reader in ~750 pages could be edited into probably 300 pages. Mann seems to be obsessed with eating breakfast, because it seems that half the novel is describing their meals. The novel itself is long, tedious, and so meticiously divided that the reader wonders if [the author] spent more time writing the novel or diving them up into dainty sections.
I don't owe [the author] or his publishers anything. If you have a good idea why not just write it on a page and publish the one page? If you want to use the good idea to write a book it has to be entertaining or readable or at least interesting. Looking at the other reviews by people who have given it five stars I wonder if I have just read the same book. There are no new paragraphs when he changes the dialogue from one person to the next and the publishers surely should have done this for him because, in not doing so, you keep having to stop to work out who is saying what. The book just crawled along and was so boring. After about sixty pages I remember saying 'alright, I get it, do something else!' Part of me wonders if it's like the emperors new coat and I should just join in with five stars. Although the other reviewers praise the book they don't seem to actually say WHY it's a good book. It was pure mince.
I thought the movie was rather good. After about 250 pages I quit.
FHerbel - 3. Jan, 19:18
3 Kommentare - Kommentar verfassen - 0 Trackbacks